Key Differences: Payment Institution and Electronic Money Institution

The modern world of fintech has found a swarm of financial services providers that share their innovative products and services which can disrupt the approach to bank operations. The most notable of them are the Payment Institutions (PIs) and Electronic Money Institutions (EMIs). Although both entities are licensed to support the process of digital payments, they have different features, functionality, and regulations. This knowledge of the differences among them is essential to businesses wishing to decide which license to use in their operation and to those consumers who need to know the services that they are utilizing.

What is a Payment Institution?

A Payment Institution (PI) is a non-bank financial organization that is granted the right to provide payment services of various types. Regulated by laws such as the Payment Services Directive (PSD2) in the European Union, PIs serve as mediators, and bring money between two parties. Their major use is to take payment transactions, rather than to safekeep customer funds over a long period of time.

Core Services of a Payment Institution:

• Money Remittance: Services that allow the transfer of funds from a payer to a payee without the use of a payment account.
• Payment Execution: This includes credit transfers, direct debits, and transactions made through a payment card.
• Issuing Payment Instruments and Acquiring Payment Transactions: PIs can issue instruments like debit cards and process transactions on behalf of merchants.
• Payment Initiation Services (PIS): A service that initiates a payment from a user’s account with another payment service provider.

In essence, a PI focuses on the “movement” of money. They are a channel for transactions, not a store of value.

What is an Electronic Money Institution (EMI)?

An Electronic Money Institution (EMI) is a more comprehensive type of financial institution that can perform all the functions of a PI, but with one key additional capability: the ability to issue electronic money (e-money). This allows them to create and manage digital wallets, prepaid cards, and other “stored-value” solutions.

Core Services of an EMI:

• All PI Services: EMIs can provide all the payment services offered by a PI.
• Issuance of Electronic Money (E-money): This is the defining feature of an EMI. E-money is a digital substitute for cash, representing a monetary value stored on a device or server. It is issued upon the receipt of funds and is used to make payment transactions.
• Management of E-money Accounts: EMIs can hold customer funds in a “payment account” or “e-wallet,” where the funds are stored as e-money.

An electronic money institution emi is therefore a hybrid entity that not only facilitates payments but also serves as a digital store of value.

Book a free consultation

The Key Differences at a Glance

The distinctions between PIs and EMIs are centered on their core functionality, regulatory requirements, and business models.

Get a free quote and learn how we can help

Why These Differences Matter

The distinctions between PIs and EMIs have significant implications for both businesses and consumers.

For Businesses:

• Licensing and Compliance: The choice between a PI and EMI license depends entirely on the business model. A company that only wants to offer payment initiation services will likely opt for a PI license due to the lower capital requirements and simpler regulatory process. However, a business that plans to offer digital wallets or prepaid cards must secure an EMI license. The compliance burden for an emi electronic money institution is notably higher due to the need to protect stored customer funds.
• Operational Scope: An EMI license offers a much broader operational scope. A company with an electronic money license can provide services that a PI cannot, such as issuing cards and allowing users to hold an account balance. This flexibility can lead to greater revenue streams and a more integrated customer experience.

For Consumers:

• Nature of Funds: The funds held in a PI’s account are typically “in-transit” and are tied to a specific payment transaction. In contrast, funds held in an EMI’s e-wallet are a form of stored value. While both are required to be safeguarded, the legal nature and use of the funds are different.
• Service Offerings: Consumers will interact with PIs for services like one-off money transfers, while they will use EMIs for services that involve a digital account, such as mobile wallets and multi-currency accounts.

Conclusion

The terms Payment Institution and electronic money institution emi tend to be used interchangeably in the modern financial arena however what is failed to understand is that they represent two different categories of institutions. The capability of issuing and managing electronic money, which makes an EMI a store, as well as a payer, is the distinguishing factor. This one difference has resulted in a chain reaction of regulatory deviations, capital requirements and services that can be provided. With the evolving world of fintech, it is important to know these differences that happen in the world of digital finance.